Coo-Coo for Doo Doo’s Bakery

Have you ever been to a business and the line-up to purchase something was so long that you just wanted to know the reason for all the excitement? That is precisely what it was like for me when I saw Doo Doo’s Bakery’s booth at my first Butter Tart Festival in Midland, Ontario.

Most Popular Butter Tarts

Walking up and down the main street of Midland, we passed possibly hundreds of booths from bakeries from all over Ontario, selling their delicious butter tarts. Some had long lines, others had shorter ones, and everything in between. However, the longest line led to the booth for Doo-Doo’s Bakery. They had a banner and signs saying “Ontario’s best butter tarts winner”. So, of course, I was curious and stood in the long line. Shortly before I got to the cash, they had sold out.

At the time, I was more disappointed that I stood in the line as long as I did than I was over not getting the butter tarts. After all, I didn’t know what I was missing…. but I was still curious.

Butter tart Judge

Fast forward a couple of years later, and I was honoured to be a judge at the 2019 Ontario’s best butter tart festival. I swore that once my shift was over, I was heading to Doo Doo’s booth to get some tarts. By the time I got there, they were already sold out. DARN! I missed out again. The same thing happened when we also attended the Paris Butter Tart Festival.

Why the Ballyhoo?

Doo Doo’s Bakery has been the recipient of many accolades, awards, certificates, and trophies over the years – hailing their tarts as the “Best Butter Tarts”. Diane Rogers and her team have won many competitions and festivals across Ontario – you can find a list of her accomplishments here. These awards have helped them become the butter tarts people will wait in line to get at these festivals. Her booth is one of the most sought-after in the festival circuit. People will make a beeline for Doo Doo’s Bakery and snap up packages of her sweet treats.

Roadtrip to Bailieboro

I was now more determined than ever to get some of these butter tarts for our butter tart quest. First, I had to figure out when I would make a road trip to Doo Doo’s bakery & café shop in Bailieboro.

There is just one thing….. Where exactly is Bailieboro?

Our close friends moved to a farm north of Belleville, and on a road trip to visit them, I saw a sign for Bailieboro, so we made a quick exit off the 401, and we were now headed toward Peterborough.
Was it on the way? NO! But was it necessary – YES!
We made it to Doo-Doo’s Bakery & Café in Bailieboro. I was finally going to be able to get my hands on those elusive butter tarts. Woo Hoo

“We Bake Fresh every Day. We do everything by hand & it sure does pay off in the taste of the tart”
– Diane Rogers

The Butter Tarts

Upon entering Doo Doo’s Bakery & Café, you will first see the award-winning butter tarts on display in the pastry case and many of their awards decorating the store. They have many different flavours to choose from, including plain, raisin, walnut, & pecan. Other less traditional flavours are cherry, raspberry coconut, maple whisky, maple bacon, and many others. They also offer a variety of seasonal flavours, which change throughout the year.


The butter tarts from Doo Doo’s have a very rustic and hand-made appearance. While all of the tarts are appropriately baked, some are darker, and some are lighter in colour. None of the butter tarts were burnt or overbaked. No two butter tarts look exactly alike, which is precisely how we like them. You can tell each butter tart is created by hand with love and passion.


The pastry of these butter tarts is very light, flaky, and sweet. It is a thick crust but is also very delicate and buttery. The taste is exquisite.


The filling has a pleasant sweet taste, smooth texture, and rich buttery flavour. It has an excellent ooze factor. The filling is not too runny but just enough to be decadent. A delicious caramelisation is on the top for a light candy crunch, which adds to the joy of eating a Doo Doo’s butter tart.

Crust-to-Filling Ratio

The ratio is outstanding. You get to enjoy the taste of the creamy filling and the buttery sweet crust together in every bite.

Overall Experience

This is a truly decadent tart. It has a great taste from start to finish. It is a delightfully sweet tart, that is a pleasure to eat and enjoy.

Notes on Raisins

The raisin tart has a lot of raisins in the filling, but unlike most raisin butter tarts – this one does not taste like a raisin tart. The raisins do not take over the flavour – they are just a part of it. Usually I am a “no raisins’ kind of person, but Doo Doo’s is one of those bakeries where it is proof that if they make a really good butter tart – the raisins don’t ruin it.

Was it Worth the Hype?

Absolutely. Time and time again, Doo Doo’s Bakery is voted the best butter tart in Ontario at many Butter tart festivals. Doo Doo’s deserves all of the awards and accolades they have received for their butter tarts. They are a fantastic tart – full of rich flavours proving a decadent eating experience when you bite into one.
Now that we know where Bailieboro is, we have made the stop at Doo Doo’s several times, and we have been able to get them at more local butter tart festivals as well.

Doo Doo’s Bakery is a charming little country store, bakery, and café a short distance south of Peterborough. They have a seating area of approximately 6-8 tables where customers can enjoy breakfast, pastries, and coffee.
In addition to their decadent butter tarts, they serve other fabulous baked goods like cookies, pies, squares, and sausage rolls. In the warmer months, you can also enjoy Kawartha dairy ice cream.

Follow our Hashtag: #ButterTartQuest for more great locations



If you are in the area of the Kawarthas, be sure to check out the many other bakeries on the Kawarthas Northumberland Butter Tart Tour.



*note: All butter tart reviews are our opinions only, based on our experiences and personal preferences. Your experiences and opinion may vary.

If you know of the best bakeries in Ontario making what you think are Ontario’s Best butter tarts, we would love to hear from you.                         Contact Roguetrippers with your suggestions.


Adventurer, gastro-tourist, avid road tripper, and butter tart aficionado. Exploring the road less travelled and the adventures that exist for all to see if you open yourself up to new possibilities. Greg and his husband Nick are residents of Guelph, and their greatest joys in life are exploring the world around them. Road trips with no real destination are a favourite past time. Get off the beaten path and discover somewhere they have never been before. Sometimes the best vacations are the ones you don't really plan. Life is about the journey together and not the destination.


  1. I also worship at the alter of Diane Rogers and her Doo Doo’s bakery. Her butter tart is the platonic ideal of the form. If aliens were to come down and demand, in a threatening manner, of our earth representatives an example of our planet’s butter tart, one could rest assured that a Doo Doo’s butter tart could be provided with a sure hand and a confident visage. All hail Doo Doo’s!

    • Doo-Doo’s are amazing. They are even better when they are fresh out of the oven. If we are ever in the area near Bailieboro we always stop in. even if it is not on the way. 🙂

  2. jamie newman Reply

    Agreed. I had my tart when it was slightly warm and it is unparalleled in my experience- and I am someone who has completed both the butter tart tour and the butter tart trail.

Write A Comment